Call Us Today
Call Us Today
Steve Kherkher - March 5, 2026
Heart valve replacement surgery is intended to restore quality of life and protect patients from serious cardiac complications. For many people, receiving an artificial or bioprosthetic heart valve offers the promise of improved health and longevity. Unfortunately, some medical devices have raised safety concerns after being linked to early failure and serious complications. Aortic heart valve failure lawsuits continue to emerge against Abbott for one of their more popular devices.
In recent years, lawsuits and safety alerts involving the Abbott Trifecta heart valve have drawn national attention. Patients who received this valve and later experienced complications may have questions about their health, their legal rights, and whether the device may have failed prematurely.
At Kherkher Garcia, we represent individuals and families affected by dangerous or defective medical devices. When a medical implant fails earlier than expected, the consequences can be life-altering. Below, our product liability attorneys discuss how you can protect your rights after a defective device injury.
The heart contains four valves that regulate blood flow. The aortic valve is responsible for controlling blood flow from the heart into the body’s largest artery, the aorta. When the aortic valve becomes damaged due to disease, aging, or congenital conditions, it may not function properly. This condition is known as aortic valve disease and can include:
In severe cases, patients may require aortic valve replacement surgery, in which the damaged valve is replaced with either a mechanical valve or a bioprosthetic valve made from animal tissue.
Bioprosthetic valves are often chosen because they typically do not require lifelong blood-thinning medication. However, they are expected to function reliably for many years. When they fail prematurely, patients may face serious health risks.
The Abbott Trifecta heart valve is a bioprosthetic aortic valve made from bovine (cow) tissue. It was designed to mimic natural valve function while providing improved blood flow. The valve gained widespread use after receiving regulatory approval and was implanted in thousands of patients worldwide.
However, over time, reports began to emerge suggesting that some Trifecta valves may experience early structural deterioration. SVD can lead to complications such as:
For many patients, the most concerning issue has been the unexpectedly early failure of the valve. In some cases, failure occurred within only a few years of implantation.
In response to growing reports of early valve failure, safety concerns about the Trifecta valve have been raised by regulatory agencies and medical researchers. Regulators and manufacturers have issued communications warning healthcare providers about the potential risk of early SVD.
In 2023, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) sent notice to healthcare providers about the risks of SVD. Later in 2023, Abbott stopped sales and distribution of the Trifecta valves.
For patients, these warnings can raise difficult questions about whether their implanted valve could fail earlier than expected.
When a bioprosthetic valve fails, patients may experience symptoms similar to those seen with untreated aortic valve disease. Common symptoms of aortic heart valve failure may include:
In severe cases, valve failure may lead to:
Because symptoms may develop gradually, patients may not immediately realize their valve is deteriorating. Anyone who has received a Trifecta valve and experiences new or worsening cardiac symptoms should seek medical attention as soon as possible.
Aortic valve replacement surgery is a major procedure that requires significant recovery time. Patients often undergo the surgery with the expectation that the replacement valve will function for many years. When a valve fails prematurely, patients may face a number of challenges, including:
For older patients or those with other health conditions, repeat surgery may carry especially high risk. Furthermore, families may face emotional and financial stress as they navigate additional treatment.
As reports of early valve deterioration increased, patients across the country began filing aortic heart valve failure lawsuits related to the Trifecta device. These lawsuits generally allege that the manufacturer failed to adequately warn doctors and patients about the risk of premature valve failure.
Patients are still coming forward to explore their legal rights after SVD or other heart valve injuries. Claims in these cases may include allegations such as:
Each case depends on specific facts, including medical records, device history, and expert evaluation. Product liability lawsuits involving medical devices often require extensive investigation and expert testimony.
Individuals who may wish to explore legal options include patients who:
Family members may also have the right to pursue a claim if a loved one died following complications related to a defective heart valve. Because medical device litigation can involve complex legal and medical questions, consultation with an experienced product liability attorney is often helpful.
Medical implants are designed to improve and save lives. Patients trust that the devices used in surgery have been carefully tested and evaluated for safety. They also expect that if a device is found defective, that manufacturers will remove the item from the market.
When a medical device fails unexpectedly, it raises concerns about whether proper testing, monitoring, and safety oversight were followed. Legal claims can play an important role in uncovering safety issues and encouraging improvements in medical device design and regulation.
Many bovine tissue valves can last 10 to 20 years. Premature failure within a significantly shorter period may raise medical and legal questions.
Structural valve deterioration (SVD) refers to physical damage or breakdown of the valve’s tissue components, which can affect its ability to function properly.
Your cardiologist or surgeon should have records identifying the specific valve model used during your procedure. Lack of such a record would be a red flag.
Not necessarily. Each case depends on the specific medical facts and circumstances. An attorney can review your medical records to determine whether a claim may exist.
Depending on the case, damages may include medical expenses, lost income, pain and suffering, and other losses related to the injury. Every case is unique, which is why careful investigation into your situation is crucial.
Cases involving defective medical devices require careful investigation and coordination with medical experts. These cases often involve complex scientific and regulatory issues.
Kherkher Garcia has experience representing individuals harmed by dangerous medical devices and defective products. Our team works to evaluate medical records, consult with experts, and identify whether a device failure may have contributed to your injuries.
We believe that patients and families deserve answers when a medical device fails earlier than expected.
If you or a loved one received an Abbott Trifecta heart valve and later experienced complications or early valve failure, you may have questions about your legal options. Kherkher Garcia offers free, confidential consultations to review potential claims related to defective medical devices.
Our team is committed to helping patients and families understand their rights and pursue accountability where appropriate. To find out if you qualify for an aortic heart valve failure lawsuit, contact Kherkher Garcia today. Call 713-333-1030 to speak with an attorney. You can also reach out to us via our website contact form. We are here to listen, answer your questions, and help you understand the next steps.
Image by Freepik
This page has been written, edited, and reviewed by a team of legal writers following our comprehensive editorial guidelines. This page was approved by attorneys Steve Kherkher and Jesus Garcia Jr., who have more than 50 years of combined legal experience championing the rights of those who have experienced catastrophic injury due to negligence.
Connect with a Kherkher Garcia trial lawyer today to pursue maximum compensation for your injury.
Message Us 
Call Us